Today I felt that I should make a long post on the subject
of freedom of speech. It came about as a result of reading that some young ‘influencer’
(God, how I hate that term) called Andrew Tate has had some of his social media
accounts closed down because of the unacceptable nature of their content.
His opinions run along similar lines to those who objected
to the suffragette movement in the 19th century. He says things like
‘there is no such thing as an independent woman’, ‘women must take
responsibility for sexual abuse’, and ‘if I’m to be responsible for a woman, I
must have authority over her.’
Strong stuff, eh? And wholly unacceptable to somebody like
me, but does he have a right to hold such opinions? Of course he does; we all
have a right to our opinions. So, second question: does he have the right to
express those opinions to the size of audience now available to him through
social media?
My first instinct is to say that he does, because the right
to express opinions is fundamental to our modern concept of democracy and our
holding to more liberal mores regarding freedom of speech than those to which
our ancestors subscribed. But it isn’t that simple because the problem here is
the size of the audience.
Let’s go back a few decades and ask whether Hitler had the
right to preach Nazi ideology, which included the opinion that Jews are the
world’s pariah and should be physically attacked and ultimately annihilated. If
you hold to that view, then you must stop blaming Hitler for the Holocaust and
blame the German people instead. Hitler was expressing an opinion to a mass
audience; it was the audience who went along with him. Not simple, is it?
Personally, I would like to see Mr Tate dropped into a deep,
dark hole from which there is no escape and with only Donald Trump for company,
but that’s just my opinion.
Other news:
I had a fall today. I was coming down a ladder, having just
trimmed part of the tall hedge at the bottom of my garden, when the distorting
effect of my eye protection goggles fooled me into thinking that the second
step at the bottom was actually the first. I ended up flat on my back on the
unremitting tarmac of the lane.
It was a little embarrassing. My first thought was that some
vehicle might, just at that inopportune moment, be coming around the bend a
little further up the lane. It might even have been the Lady B, and how
terrible would that have been? Her Land Rover Discovery might have run over me
and reduced me to a soggy mess (rather than the merely weak and ineffectual
mess to which I readily admit.) And even if she’d managed to stop in time, it
would still have given her a shock, poor thing, and she might have been forced
to admit – maybe even orally, though I doubt it – that she would rather I
didn’t die just yet.
No such catastrophe ensued, however, and the only injury I
sustained was to my pride. I’m highly averse to being so clumsy as to be
reduced to a supine position on a public road, you see. It’s indecorous to say
the least.